Christopher Uggen, Jeff Manza, and Angela Behrens. 2004. “Less than the Average Citizen: Stigma, Role Transition, and
the Civic Reintegration of Convicted Felons.” Pages 258-290
in After Crime and Punishment: Ex-Offender Reintegration and Desistance from
Crime, edited by Shadd Maruna
and Russ Immarigeon.
ABSTRACT
We ask
how criminal offenders define successful reintegration into work, family, and community
life and how role transitions across these domains are linked to an identity as
a deviant or law-abiding citizen. We examine data from semi-structured
interviews with prisoners, parolees, and probationers in developing a life
course model of role transitions and desistance based on Matsueda
and Heimer's (1997) symbolic interactionist
theory. The interview data suggest that successful role transitions across
socioeconomic, familial, and civic domains contribute to an emerging identity
as a law-abiding citizen. Unfortunately, ex-felons have difficulty establishing
the social relationships and role commitments necessary to stabilize or
solidify these emerging identities. We find that offenders are attuned to the
stigma of a felony conviction and concerned about the civil disabilities that
limit their civic participation. Nevertheless, most are eager to establish or
reestablish adult roles as productive workers, responsible family members, and
active citizens. In fact, formal punishment and the concomitant barriers to
establishing or reestablishing these roles seem to engender a new or renewed
appreciation of their importance.