Uggen,
Christopher and Jeremy Staff.
2001. “Work as a Turning Point for Criminal Offenders.” Corrections Management Quarterly 5:1-16.
[Reprinted 2003 in Crime and Employment: Critical Issues in Crime Reduction for
Corrections, edited by Jessie L. Krienert and
Mark S. Fleisher. Rowman and Littlefield].
ABSTRACT
This
paper considers whether employment is a "turning point" in the lives
of criminal offenders. We present a brief overview of research on the
relationship between work and crime, centering on three basic questions: (1) Are job programs more effective for older
than for younger offenders? (2) Are ex-offenders who get “good jobs” more
likely to desist from crime than those who get marginal work? And, (3) can work
programs reduce drug use or the economic crime associated with drug use for
ex-addicts? We briefly explain each
research problem, outline previous program evaluations and research, and then
provide provisional answers with some illustrative evidence. Our review suggests that work programs appear
to be more effective for adult offenders than for adolescents and young adults.
The quality of employment also appears to be important for reducing recidivism,
although it is difficult to make definitive causal inferences based on
observational evidence from existing studies. Finally, we find that work-based
programs can reduce arrest rates for ex-addicts, but appear to be less
effective in reducing future substance use. We conclude with several unanswered
questions and directions for future research.